How Plant-Based Diets vs. Omnivorous Diets Influence Fertility Markers

Your diet influences your overall health, but did you know it can also play a major role in your fertility? In this article, we explore how plant-based diets and omnivorous diets affect key fertility markers, based on evidence from an 8-week clinical trial. By the end of this, you’ll have a better idea of how your food choices could support your journey to conception.

Pregatips.com
food labels
What you eat affects your hormones, weight, gut health, and metabolic functions, all of which are tightly linked to your reproductive health. While many people are now exploring plant-based diets for ethical or environmental reasons, there's growing curiosity around whether they can support fertility just as well or even better than an omnivorous diet.



The truth is, both diets can offer benefits if followed mindfully. But recent research, especially a study published in JAMA Network Open, sheds some light on how going vegan may influence health markers that directly or indirectly impact fertility.

Researchers selected 22 pairs of genetically identical twins to ensure a controlled and unbiased comparison. For an 8-week duration, one twin adhered to a vegan (plant-based) diet, while the other followed an omnivorous eating pattern.

Here’s what made this study special:

  • Twins were genetically identical, so any health differences were likely due to the diet alone.
  • Meals were planned and provided for 4 weeks and self-prepared for the next 4.
  • Both diets were kept “healthy”, lots of whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, and minimal junk or processed food.

Key Health Markers Monitored

The study looked at:

  • LDL cholesterol (often called “bad” cholesterol)
  • Fasting insulin levels
  • Body weight
  • Vitamin B12 levels
  • Trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO), a marker associated with heart and gut health
  • Glucose levels
These markers aren’t just about your heart, they’re linked to how your body processes energy, manages inflammation, and regulates hormones, all of which are essential when trying to conceive.

By the end of 8 weeks, the vegan twin had:

  • Lower LDL cholesterol (by about 13.9 mg/dL)
  • Lower fasting insulin levels
  • More weight loss (about 1.9 kg)
  • A drop in TMAO levels could mean your gut and metabolic health are on the right track
Meanwhile, the omnivorous twin didn’t show these same improvements.

Now, this doesn’t mean that a vegan diet is the only way. But it suggests that it may offer added metabolic benefits, especially if you’re trying to manage your weight or regulate insulin both important for fertility.

How Do These Findings Relate to Fertility?

Let’s connect the dots.

Lower insulin levels can help support better ovulation and hormonal balance.
Healthy cholesterol levels improve blood flow to reproductive organs. Weight loss (when needed) supports regular cycles and hormone regulation. Improved gut health from plant-based fibre may reduce inflammation and support overall hormone function.

A plant-rich diet, especially one that’s thoughtfully planned, may improve your body’s inner environment, making it more fertility-friendly.


What About Nutrients Like B12 or Iron?

Yes, vegan diets do run the risk of certain nutrient deficiencies, especially:

  • Vitamin B12
  • Iron
  • Calcium
These nutrients are crucial for energy, healthy eggs and sperm, and overall pregnancy outcomes. If you’re choosing to go plant-based, it’s important to:

  • Plan your meals carefully
  • Include fortified foods
  • Consult a doctor for possible supplements

What If You’re Not Ready to Go Fully Plant-Based?

That’s okay! You don’t have to give up all animal products to support fertility.
Instead, you could:

  • Nourish your body with more plant-powered goodness, whole grains, legumes, fruits, and veggies are a great place to start.
  • Cut down on processed meat and sugary snacks.
  • Try "plant-forward" meals a few times a week.

What This Means for You

Whether you're vegan, vegetarian, or omnivorous, your diet is a powerful tool in your fertility journey. The key isn’t picking one side but making smart, nutrient-rich food choices consistently.

If you're trying to conceive, start by focusing on:

  • Eating the rainbow, fruits and veggies in all colours
  • Swapping refined grains with whole grains
  • Adding legumes and nuts to your meals
  • Drinking enough water
  • Limiting ultra-processed foods
A healthy diet can shape your fertility journey in more ways than one. While both plant-based and omnivorous diets can support reproductive health, a thoughtfully planned vegan diet may offer added cardiometabolic benefits like lower insulin and cholesterol levels that can indirectly support better fertility. That said, there's no one-size-fits-all solution. Your ideal diet depends on your body, lifestyle, and medical needs. The best step forward? Speak to your doctor or fertility expert, listen to your body, and start nourishing it with foods that support both health and hope.


FAQs on How Plant-Based Diets vs. Omnivorous Diets Influence Fertility Markers

  1. Can a vegan diet improve my fertility?
    It may help improve insulin sensitivity, reduce inflammation, and support hormonal balance, all key for fertility. Just make sure it’s planned right so you don’t miss out.
  2. Will cutting out meat hurt my chances of conceiving?
    As long as you're nourishing your body with all the right nutrients, you're on the right path, meat or no meat.
  3. What if I feel too tired on a vegan diet?
    A deficiency in iron or vitamin B12 could be contributing to these symptoms. It’s a good idea to get your blood tested and ask your doctor about any supplements you might need.
  4. How soon can I expect changes in my fertility markers if I change my diet?
    Some changes, like improved insulin or cholesterol levels, may happen in a few weeks. But fertility takes time, and consistency is key.
Disclaimer: Medically approved by Dr Sukirti Jain Consultant Obstetrics and Gynaecology Cloudnine Group of Hospitals, Navi Mumbai, Vashi